Erroneous Causality Argument
In my classes when I cover research methods, I show some newspaper articles that appropriately or inappropriately argue causality. I think it’s nice to show that journalists (and researchers) often read more into their data than they should, but it’s also nice to make the point about 3rd variables and reverse causality problems.
Here‘s a great example I got from Yahoo’s news site. The headline: Sexual Lyrics Prompt Teens to Have Sex. They provide little hint of the possibility that kids who have sex are drawn to music that contains such lyrics. Even the researchers make this assertion without acknowledging alternative explanations.
I’m not sayin’ that the claim is wrong, just that they don’t have the basis for the argument, at least beyond speculation.
Old Drug Ads
My, how our perceptions of drug treatment have changed! Take a look at some of these ads, many of which are for treatment of psychological disorders.
via Folderol
-
Recent
- Back after a long hiatus
- Critical Thinking Can Save Your Job…
- Multitasking Limits in the Popular Press
- “Fixation” Has Different Meanings to Different People
- The Myth of the Down Low
- The Psychology of the NCAA Tournament Office Pool
- Metacognition in Rats
- Familiar Smells and Sleep Aid Memory
- Face Recognition from Minimal Pixelation
- College Students More Narcissistic
- Risk Assessment and the NFL Draft
- Whither Stigma?
-
Links
-
Archives
- October 2007 (1)
- March 2007 (8)
- February 2007 (8)
- October 2006 (5)
- September 2006 (12)
- August 2006 (10)
-
Categories
-
RSS
Entries RSS
Comments RSS